So, according to your new definition of Socialism, if people have to pay taxes to support a government like Social Security or Obamacare, that program is not socialist? Elsewhere in this article you use the term "quasi-socialism". Are you saying quasi socialism is ---not--- partly socialism? If paying taxes makes something not "real" socialism, can you give an example of what in your view is ---real--- socialism? Co-ops? But co-ops are non-governmental. As a Trump supporting libertarian Republican, I love co-ops, communes, and private sector unions precisely because none of these are governmental. Are you defining ---real--- socialism as non-governmental organization? If so, I wholeheartedly support your vision of real socialism.