When you say the word "socialism" people think "government programs". People don't think of Kibbutzes, which almost no one has heard of. I define Kibbutzes as libertarian. I agree with you that labels are often inaccurate, even self-labels. You accuse the Nazis of wrongly labeling themselves socialists; I accuse the Kibbutzes of wrongly labeling themselves socialists. A decent classification system of labels will be simple and have as simple to understand differences as possible that are as objective as possible. You are trying to call the Nazis not socialist based not upon actions or results, but your own value judgments about whether the Nazis were truly working for the people. My definitions on the other hand are clear and objective: Different political terms describe the different sorts of actions that governments take: https://medium.com/non-violence/defining-socialism-fascism-communism-capitalism-libertarianism-anarchism-1f30ba6067e - How involved is the government in regulating the economy and society.